I WANTED TO KNOW: Did We Get Butter Wrong? 🧈
We gave up butter, embraced margarine, and spent decades worrying about saturated fat. But was that actually good advice? I went looking for answers.
Thanksgiving is coming, which means we're about to use approximately a gazillion pounds of butter. In the stuffing. The mashed potatoes. The pies. Basically, if it tastes good, there's a decent chance butter had something to do with it.
And somewhere, someone is trying to make the whole meal "healthier" by taking the butter out. But should we?
For years, I was an olive oil devotee. I cooked practically everything with it. Then I started reading about ghee, which is clarified butter, and its supposed health benefits. I tried it, loved it, and started using it in practically everything. I even make popcorn with ghee. That's how serious this relationship has become.
Changing the way I eat has also made me question some of the nutritional advice I've accepted for years. So I started wondering: Did we get butter wrong?
First, Remember Margarine?
If you're of a certain age, you remember when butter became practically a public enemy. Saturated fat was bad. Cholesterol was bad. Butter was bad. Margarine was good. Or so we were told.
We switched to margarine and other butter substitutes. Some even came in tubs that screamed HEALTHY. Then researchers discovered something inconvenient. Many older margarines contained partially hydrogenated oils, which produced artificial trans fats. Those trans fats were linked to increased cardiovascular risk, and in 2015, the FDA ruled that partially hydrogenated oils were no longer recognized as safe to add to food.
Most uses were eventually phased out of the American food supply. Wait. The stuff we were told to eat instead of butter turned out to be a problem?
Well, that was awkward.
But here's where I had to stop myself. Just because some old margarines were bad for us doesn't automatically mean butter was good for us. And today's soft margarines made with unsaturated vegetable oils are not the same products we were eating decades ago.
Then I Fell in Love With Ghee
Ghee is butter that's been heated until most of the water and milk solids are removed. It can handle higher cooking temperatures than ordinary butter, and the flavor? Fantastic. Rich, nutty, delicious. At some point, I started treating it like olive oil's smarter, better-looking cousin.
And when I read that ghee contains butyrate, a fatty acid that helps nourish the cells lining our colon, I thought I'd really discovered something. But here's what I learned. Yes, ghee contains some butyrate. And yes, butyrate plays an important role in gut health.
But the amount you get from eating ghee is relatively small. Most of the butyrate in our colon is produced by gut bacteria fermenting certain dietary fibers. In other words, putting ghee on everything isn't necessarily doing your gut any special favors. And because the water is cooked off, a spoonful of ghee actually has a bit more saturated fat than a spoonful of butter. Oops.
I was beginning to suspect my favorite new ingredient wasn't quite the nutritional superstar I'd imagined.
So What Does the Research Actually Say?
This is where I had to put aside my personal preferences.
A major 2020 Cochrane review looked at randomized trials involving about 56,000 people. Researchers found that reducing saturated fat was associated with about 17% fewer cardiovascular events, although they found little or no effect on overall mortality.
And a 2025 study published in JAMA Internal Medicine followed more than 221,000 adults.
People who consumed the most butter had a 15% higher relative risk of death during follow-up than those who consumed the least. Oddly, the link was to cancer deaths, not heart deaths. People who consumed more plant-based oils, including olive oil, generally had lower mortality. Not exactly the butter victory parade I was hoping for.
But before anyone throws out their butter dish, there's an important distinction. That second study was observational. It found associations, not proof that butter caused those outcomes. People who eat more butter may differ from people who don't in other ways that affect their health.
But the broader evidence still favors replacing some saturated fat with unsaturated fat, particularly for cardiovascular health. Which brings me back to my old friend, olive oil. Apparently, I may have abandoned a perfectly good relationship.
Does That Mean Butter Is Bad?
Not necessarily. And I think this is where nutrition advice often goes off the rails. We want a verdict. Good food. Bad food. Eat this. Never eat that. But the more useful question is often: What are you eating instead? Replacing some butter with olive oil or another oil rich in unsaturated fats is supported by cardiovascular research. Replacing it with something full of refined carbohydrates isn't necessarily an improvement.
And enjoying butter in a favorite recipe is different from making it your primary cooking fat every day.
Butter also contains vitamin A and small amounts of other nutrients. But having some nutritional benefits doesn't automatically make a food heart-healthy.
I think we've spent too much time looking for heroes and villains in the grocery store. And not enough time asking what the evidence actually says.
My Thanksgiving Verdict
I'm not taking butter out of my Thanksgiving recipes. And I'm certainly not taking it out of my corn casserole, which happens to be this week's Savvy Planet recipe.
I'm also not throwing away my ghee. I love cooking with it. And sometimes flavor is a perfectly legitimate reason to use an ingredient. But I'm going to keep olive oil in the rotation, too. I started this investigation hoping to give butter a full pardon. The evidence didn't quite let me.
What I learned is that the old advice wasn't entirely wrong. Replacing some saturated fat with unsaturated fat really does appear to be beneficial for cardiovascular health. What went wrong was treating every butter substitute as automatically healthier, including products we later discovered contained harmful trans fats.
Butter isn't poison. It isn't a miracle, either. And one Thanksgiving dinner doesn't determine our long-term health.
As for my ghee? There's still a jar next to my stove. Some relationships are complicated.
Sources and Further Reading
-
FDA: Final Determination Regarding Partially Hydrogenated Oils: The regulatory history of artificial trans fats.
-
Cochrane, 2020: Reduction in Saturated Fat Intake for Cardiovascular Disease: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials examining saturated fat reduction and cardiovascular outcomes.
-
JAMA Internal Medicine, 2025: Butter and Plant-Based Oils Intake and Mortality: A large prospective observational study comparing butter and plant-oil consumption.
-
American Heart Association: Saturated Fats: Current guidance on saturated fats and substituting unsaturated fats.
-
Cleveland Clinic: Separating Ghee Fact From Fiction: A clinical overview of ghee and its nutritional properties.
This article is based on published research and personal experience. It is not individualized medical advice.